Choosing the Right Privacy-Focused Analytics Tool: A Comparison of Umami vs Plausible

Tweet
Share
Share
Pin

In the world of digital marketing and website optimization, web analytics tools are crucial. However, with growing concerns over privacy, many businesses are looking for alternatives to the standard tools like Google Analytics. Two privacy-conscious options that are gaining popularity are Umami and Plausible. Both offer a simple, user-friendly approach to tracking website performance while respecting user privacy. In this blog post, we’ll compare these two tools to help you determine which one fits your needs best.

What are Umami and Plausible?

Before diving into the comparison, let’s quickly define both tools:

  • Umami is an open-source web analytics platform that prides itself on its simplicity and privacy. It’s a great option for users looking for a flexible, customizable solution that they can host themselves or use via a hosted version.
  • Plausible, also open-source, offers a clean, minimalist dashboard for tracking website performance with a strong focus on privacy. It’s designed to be easy to use, offering simple and clear data that anyone can interpret.

Key Features Comparison

Let’s look at how these two tools stack up against each other when it comes to core features.

FeatureUmamiPlausible
Open Source✅ Yes (MIT License)✅ Yes (AGPL License)
Self-Hosting✅ Supported✅ Supported
Hosted Version✅ Available at umami.is✅ Available at plausible.io
Privacy-Focused✅ No cookies, GDPR-compliant✅ No cookies, GDPR-compliant
DashboardCustomizable, cleanMinimalist, user-friendly UI
Real-Time Data✅ Yes✅ Yes
Event Tracking✅ Yes (Custom events supported)✅ Yes (Custom events supported)
Goal Tracking✅ Yes✅ Yes
Multi-Site Support✅ Unlimited sites with one account✅ Yes, but limited by plan
Email Reports❌ Not built-in✅ Yes
API Access✅ Full REST API✅ Yes

Privacy and Compliance

Both tools are committed to privacy and comply with GDPR and other data protection regulations:

  • Umami: It does not use cookies or track personal data. It anonymizes IP addresses to ensure the privacy of your visitors.
  • Plausible: Likewise, it’s cookie-free and complies with GDPR. It anonymizes all IP addresses and provides a clear, transparent approach to data handling.

For businesses and websites focusing on protecting user data, both Umami and Plausible offer peace of mind with their privacy-focused policies.

User Experience

  • Umami offers a customizable dashboard that allows developers to tweak the platform to their specific needs. It’s slightly more hands-on, which makes it a good choice for users with technical know-how who prefer flexibility and control over their data.
  • Plausible, on the other hand, focuses on a beautiful, minimalist design with simplicity at its core. Its user interface is more polished and ideal for users who don’t want to deal with a steep learning curve. It also sends email reports, a nice feature for busy business owners who want quick updates without logging into the platform constantly.

Pricing

When it comes to pricing, Umami has a clear advantage for those who are comfortable with self-hosting. It’s completely free to host yourself, and if you choose to use the hosted version, it starts at a low price of ~$9/month.

Plausible, while also affordable, comes with a hosted pricing model. It starts at €9/month, depending on the volume of traffic your site generates. Unfortunately, it does not offer a free tier for hosted services, although there is a 30-day trial to give you a taste of the features before committing to a plan.

Best Use Case

  • Choose Umami if you have technical expertise or a development team that can handle self-hosting. It’s ideal for those who need a more customizable and flexible solution, including multi-site tracking.
  • Choose Plausible if you’re looking for a simple, no-fuss, hosted solution with a beautiful design and intuitive dashboard. It’s perfect for businesses that don’t have the resources to manage self-hosting and want a quick, easy way to get started with web analytics.

Conclusion

Both Umami and Plausible are excellent choices for privacy-conscious website owners looking for alternatives to more invasive tracking tools like Google Analytics. If you want full control and flexibility, Umami might be the better choice, especially if you’re comfortable with self-hosting. However, if you prefer a polished, hosted solution with minimal setup, Plausible is a solid option that delivers the essentials in a user-friendly package.

Ultimately, your choice will depend on your specific needs, technical expertise, and whether you prefer a self-hosted or hosted service. Either way, you can’t go wrong with these privacy-first analytics tools.